Reviews for SoulEater: Maka

[kiaraneko]

Awesome

Really great pic!!! And I acually think the arm is coming towards the viewer, so I think the glove has the right size and the arm the rigth length, but the arm would have to become a little thicker towars the glove. And it looks like the scythe is broken. Since the holder at the right bottom is definetly drawn as if it leads behind (wich is right, I think), but the part of the stack in the top looks as if its paralel to the view. This meens the scythe must be either broken or has an angle (well maybe it has I acually dunno the series)
But still this is an awesome pic!

exninja123 responds:

lol
yeah pretty much the whole picture was unproportional XD
anyways thanks! :D

[deathslayer]

I like the character alot.

But I agree with LegolaSS, her scythe looks like a blow up toy, her arm is a little too short while her hand is too big.

It's still good though, like the hair.

exninja123 responds:

thanks! :D

[LegolaSS]

Lovely face

the face and hair are both clean and done very well... however i feel that the sythe looks almost like a giant chilly the way its shaded and highlighted.. her legs look tiny and her arm going towards her glove is either to small... or if its not coming towards us the glove is to big along with the hand... i hope you can see where needs work and improve it... :3

exninja123 responds:

thanks! :D