this
made the least sense of any music video ive ever seen good animation tho
Reviews for ".:Cupcakes:."
I kind of want to dislike this for the subject matter...but I still seem to enjoy it. The music could not have been better synched, or better chosen; and the animation was generally of a very good quality. There were some moments that were positively artful. Rainbow Dash being alarmed as we see her wings carefully spread out behind the slab, and Pinkie Pie gingerly biting down on the chainsaw before she sets it up were particularly memorable. I also really liked the transition to the torture room, and the stuffed heads of disappeared characters hanging on the wall was a very nice touch (even if Angel Bunny didn't really fit with the others.)
Unfortunately, this wasn't without it's flaws. The marionette dancing in the intermediate sequences looked jerky and kind of ugly (even if I did like seeing wingless Rainbow Dash dancing.) I can see how it may have been intentional, but that doesn't actually make it better. Not to mention the text being generally annoying. The fake credits added NOTHING WHATSOEVER and just kind of annoyed me and presumably any of the listed names (besides you) who may have seen it. Also, for the first time the text in the Author Comments box has reduced my enjoyment of the video. Your F.A.Q. comes off as unbelievably inane and pretentious. Them grabbing things happens all the time in the show so you don't need to draw attention to it.
But my biggest gripe is this: THE EYES. I can understand altering the art style at least some, but the eyes are a key part of Friendship is Magic's style. Pony eyes do not bug out, do not have particularly wrinkle-able lids, and ABSOLUTELY do not go bloodshot. I could let it slide but a ridiculous number of the shots have bloodshot eyes! It looks 'messed up' in all the WRONG ways. Besides, any way I imagine it, conveying the same level of pain and madness via bright and glassy eyes would have added another BEAUTIFUL layer of subversion and general disturbance.
All in all, a pretty impressive piece, but a number of stylistic choices and the fact that I see a little bit too much 'you' in the piece prevent me from enjoying it as much as I could.
Hng!
The music and animation is great.
But did you really have to use THAT story? It makes me nothing but cringe and cry.
That would be great without the murder
It's still unsettling to watch, even after all this time. A recent Youtube video reminded me of this, so I had to view it again.