00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

applessmillion just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "SPUD - Part 3"

Eh? It's a sad ending?

Yes, but one that can be avoided. The question is will you...
1) go on with your life as it was and have a sad ending?
2) be motivated enough to take a different path than the one so many take?

The choice is yours.

@nahtanojmal
Nice series, I hope that one day I'll be making animations similar to yours.

nahtanojmal responds:

Hey Thankyou. Awesome

It was beatiful

I'll give you a 5/9, because the animation. That could be less crude... But the message and everything else was pretty good thank you.

nahtanojmal responds:

Yeah I'm not that pro at animating. he he I think your the first person to thank me. You're welcome ;D

good

The art wasn't that great but the story was deep/good/interesting.

nahtanojmal responds:

I agree and thanks

Interesting and well done.

After watching half of this I went back and watched the first two parts before actually watching this one right through. I have to admit you have an interesting story though I feel like you just didn't delve deep enough into it. You left it a little open and ambiguous and I get the feeling that is why many people may have been off put by the fact they struggled to really follow what this is about.

I see a lot of people criticising you about your animation style though I really don't think you deserve it. The style, while simple in some regards does just fine and you have more than enough detail to play with in my opinion and to get the story across.

Characters all show some degree of depth and difference though you could have maybe gone into more of the background of why they where offered this so called "contract". Other than that good job, I'm not personally a Christian but I appreciated the ideas and concepts behind the story.

----Summary:----
Animation: 7
Style: 9
Story: 8
Overall feel: 9

nahtanojmal responds:

Thanks for the in-depth review. Much appreciated

Yup, suddenly it all starts making sense.

As with last time, great execution. As far as having what you need to tell a story without being taken out of it by amateurish graphical flaws or messy finishing, solid job. Still lacking in the animation department, there's no frame-by-frame, and the sound design could definitely use some work, there's little to no ambiance anywhere in the movie; no room tones, no wind. But for what it's worth, it did what it was supposed to.

The story is something completely different though. While I don't want to knock it for being obnoxious Christian propaganda... It's kind of obnoxious Christian propaganda lol. With this, you're slowly starting to rob the characters and the plot of its humanity by showing that the company who hired the heroes was lying to them (good, fascinating), then following up with 3 minutes of "hey, humans lie, so your life is a lie and you're evil, so go get religion, or suffer in hell after you dieeee!". I feel like I could ask you to be more subtle with the way you handle the unraveling of your metaphors, but clearly that isn't the point here. The point is to scare people into imaginary servitude, as with my little series it's very difficult for me to be subtle about my disgust with your cult, so why ask? But I cannot ignore that you have skill, and on a boring school night, it was something to watch. Keep at this, the Bible's the world's greatest horror/comedy, I'll watch anything based on it :3

nahtanojmal responds:

Thanks, I think. :D