Gushing with Character
For starters, I was blown away by the dramatic interpretation of the Newgrounds logo. That looks fantastic!
Hania once again proves to be a brilliant composer. She's improved since Tarboy, and she effectively contributed providing a wonderful atmosphere to this animation. (reads author comments) ...Err...well, me personally, I like this soundtrack better :P
The overall texture, atmosphere of the entire animation was most appealing. It was very broody, but it looked great doing it. However, it was SO broody, and so focused on the visuals that it left something to be desired in the content...
From the very beginning we're trying to understand what's going on. I have no problem with there being no dialogue, as long as what's happening is clear. Here, we don't know the significance of him turning down food, or what the apple is supposed to represent. We don't know who these three Mummy Witches are, and we don't know why he got shot out of an earthbound cannon. Nothing is clear. We don't know what this character did to deserve this, we don't know what his conflict is other than trying to get this unexplained, unestablished ring off his neck, and we don't know what he's walking towards. We don't know who or what or why he was snatched back up into the heavens, and I'm simply left to just throw my hands up and say "Whatever. It looked better than anything I could ever draw. Five!"
Where is the story? It certainly looked beautiful, but why are these things happening to....who are these people again? Where or...huh? BEAUTIFUL, yes...phenomenal animation set to phenomenal music, without a doubt.....but....What?
I don't mind that there's no dialogue, it doesn't need it. This is art in itself, and it's done to the specifications of what you were emoting THROUGH your art. At that level, it's wonderful. But at another level, there's a lot to be desired through this because I want to see where it could go. If you're not going to use any voices, grunts and cry-overs could still be welcome...even for dramatic breaths, or struggling against the pull from the sky.
The menu has smooth transitions all throughout. The music uninterrupted in the background is an underappreciated blessing (friggin' DVD's with a buttload of funding don't even have that) and the menu loop looks and sounds wonderful and mystical. Actually, that would be a pretty good word to describe the project...it's very mystical and unearthly.
It's mystical how SMOOTH some of the face animations were. You would be doing me a huge service by at least pointing out what software you used for those morphing head turns, as I'm about to take After Effects over the summer semester. (Hell, I still have to even mess around with Premier. I have so much to learn.)
You're a master at your craft, clearly. I always look forward to hearing when you got something new coming up, in fact I came from your news blog posted on the front page. Keep up the great work! This was a very juicy, very artistic and creative demonstration of your abilities, as well as Hania's ability to accentuate on an atmosphere. Once again, while I don't mind the lack of dialogue, the lack of clarity in the story is what keeps it from getting a 10. Everything else is top-notch, as far as I'm concerned.
Great job! And if you could answer my feeble software questions, you'd be a much appreciated hero. :D
