Well, here's the thing.
The animation side of it is solid besides getting the lip movement right, but I think what made it not as enjoyable for me personally was the voice acting and writing. It just sounds like either Antfish was trying too hard, or the writing just wasn't enough :-/ I got a few laughs here and there, I just wish mario wasn't temporarily possessed by spongebob squarepants :)
It's not perfect, but it's amusing little short and worth a look.
Yeah.
It was good... It was funny and nicely animated but... I noticed that you took a lot of these ideas directly from The Mario Collab which you took part in. I mean, you took some lines word for word. But, since you're a friend I'll give you a break with a 7. I don't know if it was intentional for people to notice this, but I did. Were you trying to recreate some of these scenes with better animation, or were you just low on ideas?
Not outrageously funny but it was pretty good
It's just typical Mario humor though I have to give props for originality for some things like the endin. Honestly I cant really say much else but hey you did alright!
lawl funny
what a FU! xDDD
It's nothing special
I can't say much for art, but as for animation, it works. It wasn't blocky and awkward like others.
The music isn't something I can really judge either. It fits though, as well as the sound effects.
The voice acting is pretty good. For me, sometimes I can't catch every word being said because you go higher than what I'm used to, and the pacing is fast. Mario's character has a stereotypical Italian accent for sure, but the few times he speaks, he still has clarity.
The jokes weren't bad, but they were sometimes predictable or had an awkward deliverance. That stems from the clarity of the words for me. Nothing was gut-busting, but it wasn't dirty, which I like. Comedy because someone is screaming, babbling, or doing crude potty jokes doesn't work for me.
All in all, this wasn't that bad.