Entertaining
I liked the puzzles and gameplay, and altogether it is a pretty good game. What I don't really like is the puzzles with mirrors and light - I feel like I've already played it through seeing as I've played the Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker. The puzzles seem to be more than coincidentally similar to those in the Zelda game.
Decent game
The game itself is not much of a challenge, but the atmosphere and artwork is commendable. I like that you added achievements, if you had not i probably wouldn't have tried it.
How do you unlock the replay achievement? First I tried pressing "New Game" at the end screen, completed it again, but no achievement. Then i reloaded the game, completed it, still no achievement. In the end I just let myself die to get the "first death" xD
Good Job
Decent...
The game was too easy, only one death on the second try, none on the third. I did admire the craftsmanship though, the levels looked pretty nice, and I could easily tell background from foreground, even though they weren't unpleasantly demarcated. In the caves, you can slip off the left edge of the last platform, but other than that the game seemed pretty stable.
@killants: He's not really dying if you get to start the level over again, is he?
nice job
My first criticism is that when you first begin the game and you go to the left, you jump down a cliff and can't get back up so I had to reload the page to restart the game. I'm not sure how something like that could be missed. If I wasn't so interested in game design, I wouldn't have played it all the way through. The second criticism is that it took too long for me to be able to influence anything. The first few levels of the game was just me reacting to what was going on around me. If I have the boomerang from the beginning, I should be able to use it from the beginning. Other than that, nice job and keep it up!
Alright then,
Nice game, it brings some interesting artwork and game play together. It is on the easy side though, but if another more challenging one was made, it would be an instant legend in my book.
Cheers.