Somehow a bit 'aww', allthough a lot of flaws.
Well i find it kinda..cute. The First one was so bad i didn't even get the joke of it xD I got it in the 'new' one, and had at least to chuckle a little bit. But overall way too empty, sound- and animation-wise.
But to be honest: I think you know that. That Movie is nothing but a personal, slightly funny and somehow cute parody, showing the progression.
Saying that the improvement isn't much for 8 years is a bit too relativistic. maybe you just dont hang around a lot on flash.
Also someone down there stated 'not NG Quality'. Well what IS NG-Quality? All those First-Place bunches? You can't really expect everyone to just upload 10-Star quality stuff, don't you? And laying his heart in -every- animation.
I am not sure if you really intend to make a stickfight but if you do, watch more otehr stickfight movies, get inspiration for choreography and then come again. Also work more on the sound mastering, (megaphone try: HORRIBLE!)
The only thing i really AM suprised is that this got on Frontpage. But, hey, be honest, most of you people agree with me in that point, right? Probably even the Author himself.
If someone again has the urge again, to call me an idiot and thinks my Comments are crap/bullshit, feel free to do, but please, come with a real discussion, with real arguments, with rational reason that i can agree and work on. >.> see at least i AM willing to see my faults.
Ok sorry for the last part, ending line:
Nice Little Animation, not deserving beeing Blammed, but not worth a high grade.