Hmmm
The only thing is that the spartan III's were far younger then you make them out to be.
The book Ghosts of Onyx is about the Spartan III Project led by a Spartan II survivor of Reach. Namely the one that ws launched out into space during the boarding of a covanent cruiser. I think his name was Sam... No... Gah I cant remember.
But the animation was good. So I rated on that instead of the actual story line because people are entitled to creativeness. Also the voice acting was fairly decent, unlike alot of the voicing on NG.
Plus, its NG, everytthing by everyone.