Deep
Impressive and meaningful, thoroughly enjoyed it. My only criticism would be that the trenches scene was a little empty but it was still well done with the reverse time and stuff.
Reviews for "The Lost Lake"
Good
It actually took me until the bunny to get what the train meant. Nice work on the subtlety.
I gotta say that the music choice was perfect for this. It gave a lot of power to the visuals in this piece. Even as moving as it was, I still kinda laughed when the dog got hit by an airplane.
One minor gripe, though. I liked the soldier's scene, but it felt sort of empty. The entire battle appeared to consist of him, 2 other guys, and a tank somewhere. I appreciate the work you put into showing his death (and the reverse timelapse), but seeing no other soldiers or even a gun in the other soldiers' proximity really took me out of the mood in that scene.
PapaLongLegs responds:
Yeah I had this huge war scene planned out with tons of soldiers, but when it came to doing it, thre would have been too much of a job on one guys hands!
Awsome!
I found this to be really deep. In an awesome way. Your art isn't the greatest but your style is really something.
ALTHOUGH Just some unimportant things that I've been wondering...
If it was a ghost train or whatever how did it kill the bunny?And how did the bunny get on immediately if everyone else had to get on at the station.
And more trivial things...
Why was the water already running when the guy went into the washroom?
And in the office suicide scene, that yellow coat just sort of... appears.
Even though you have a natural talent at displaying your story in a fantastic way you have to work on the little things like such.
PapaLongLegs responds:
haha well observed
Wow...
I was absolutely touched by this animation like no other. I only understood it after the man comitted suicide, but that made me go and watch it again. I love the concept, I love the animation, I just love it. Your animations are absolutely some of the best ever. Keep on making them, man. They're perfect.
OMG DAMN SAD
I Got Nothing To Say Its So Sad!!!!!!!!!!!!!