Reviews for Whistle Evaluator

[Fremen]

Great Idea

I've never seen anything like it, and I like it's originality.

Maybe you can add a part that explains to new users how whistling works and give a short (optional) whistle tutorial at the beginning.

coocooletmoi responds:

Ok, i'll include that!

[tomthecool]

Great idea!

The only improvements I think you should make are:

1. Let people see the correct answers (if they want) to reviews they marked wrong. With reasons.
2. Make it a bit longer, including a wider variety of reviews - e.g. advertising, ASCII, calling something stolen, saying "take this off the frontpage", etc.

But other than that, I think this is a really good idea you've had.
And of course, I got a deity whistle in the game, first time :D

coocooletmoi responds:

Thanks ! I'll definatly improve on it!

[Kehmicle]

cool

this was a pretty fun little test to do i got gold yay! but you could have put a few more questions in there and maybe a couple of different ways to get it up other than voting on reviews 3/5

coocooletmoi responds:

Ok, I'll see what I can do!

[amateur6]

Crap crap crap crap -- kidding.

Nicely done. One thing would improve it, IMHO -- telling you which ones you scored "incorrectly".

Fix that and it's perfect.

coocooletmoi responds:

Ok, thanks!

[zimzap]

Useful Game but Could be Improved

This was a useful game to help people with their reviewing abilities but there were two major problems with the game.

First of all, there was no music control. The music looped and got annoying very quickly. More importantly, there was no feedback given on the results besides an overall score. Users will not be able to be able to improve their reviewing ability unless they get to see which reviews they marked accurately and inaccurately.

Also a note - Your entire system is technically wrong because only successful abusive reviews increase your whistle level, marking reviews as helpful or useless has no impact so you might want to note somewhere that this is merely a simulation that does not reflect the actual whistle point system.

coocooletmoi responds:

Thanks, very helpful!