Not funny.
Animation lacked somewhat, jokes were pretty generic. Good, but not great.
Reviews for "Watchmen trailer"
Tried a bit too hard. >_>
The video wasn't bad, but it wasn't really good either. Most of the jokes seemed a bit too campy and cheesy, as if it was trying too hard to be funny.
The art-style was alright, but the actual animation left more to be desired. I will admit, the only thing that made me chuckle a little bit was the Rick Roll thing, but other than that, nothing about this video stood out to me as "great".
I suppose someone must have an aquired taste for the humor this video has. In my case, unfortunately, it was more of a "hit-and-miss" type of thing. Overall, I'll rate this a 5/10: directly in the center. As I said, it was neither bad or good to me - just average overall.
eh.
kindof funny...
and i got RICKROLLED... by Mr. Manhattan...
*Yawn*
Meh. It was ok, but the jokes... weren't actually jokes. You sorta just turned everyone into something else. Dr. Manhattan into Squidwerd, Rorschach into Rick Astley, and you had to make a Sparta joke, long after the fad had gone. Nice try pal, but it wasn't good.
An unfortunate flop.
While the animation is better than many of the submissions on newgrounds, the jokes have little to no relevance to the movie. Almost all of the humour within this flash could be applied to any other film with little variation.
Speaking of the humour, it's not very effective. Using Leonidus is a much overdone cop out and the insertion of Spongebob characters was completely Unnecessary. The Comedian's decent out the window... I understand it's slow motion, but things should only be mocked if it was overdone, which I'm sure most people will agree that was a masterfully done scene.
You have potential. The animation itself shows promise, but it could be so much better if you applied more relevant jokes. As it stands, I have to agree with 'dbz4eva' in that it doesn't seem like you've seen the film. There is so much more material to work with. Keep at it.