Warning: Loooong review ahead
Well first off I must make a point in stating that I'm not granting any leniency in my review, because of the inexperience of it's creator.
I'm always for video game sprites being used as characters, but I was dissapointed on the quality of the custom made sprites, such props could have easily been duplicated and/or improved with even MS paint. I've made .gif animations using video game sprites in the past and was able to make more convincing animations with animagic, I'd suggest using more of the character's existing sprites from FF4 for more fluidity. Also the black background just saps all emotion out of the movies atmosphere, using a background would really help.
The sound took near eternity to load on my half-assed 56k modem but was well worth it, and I suppose was less burdening to those with normal connections.
The greatest asset this movie has, was definetly it's humor, I nearly shot kiwi-strawberry juice through my nose at the part dealing with Edward's torch. Also the overall merit of FF4 meeting Survivor intrigues me, and there can never be enough Survivor spoofs.
My final verdict? A bumpy start for the series but it's room for improvement is vast. I see great potential here.