Very good idea, well executed.
Apart from a couple of technical hitches (the camera kept wobbling and sometimes de-focused), it was a really nicely made piece. Short, sweet and to the point, nice job!
Reviews for "WALL-E & R.O.B."
enjoyable
For a first time stop-motion film, this is quite amazing.
Even though the plots are very simple, it certainly grabs attention.
What the problem is, as some people might have mentioned, the frame rate.
Overall, it was ok. I can almost feel that Wall-E is moving around rather than teleporting from places to places.
The choices of characters are good. All the characters in this movie is well known, so it would be easier for us to engage the movie subconsciencely.
The use of the character was very well done. Wall-E's personality of curiosity has made this movie shine. Though some sounds that Wall-e makes added to the movie would have been terrific, but its fine.
The use of simplicity has been well used. Some people say the movie is too simple or too short. But what you've aimed for was a short movie about Wall-e and R.O.B. which is totally fine. Although we know that the movie is very simple, it would've been nice why Wall-e was tampering with ROB. (eg. why was wall-e bored, etc.)
The sound effects and the visual effects were ok. Needs a little work on the laser part. The sound effect was ok. Only thing that i would have wished for was wall-e's voice. I mean, the whole focus is about Wall-e getting his curiosity on and running away in fear from ROB. Sound effects are the most important part to consider. such as dialogues, are most important because they are the things that bring out the true emotion of the movie. Of course the visual effect would be important since the movie is about "watching" but things like dialogues or sound effects adds and creates emotions and brings the true color of the movie.
Nice use of the soundtrack "Wall-E" from OST. The music truly adds to the color of Wall-E, who is always curious.
Compared to the professional stop-motion movie, this is quite far from good. But this is a good example of what the a movie should be because: 1. the good use of the character's personality, 2. using a simple plot to make a movie enjoyable, rather than just a random clip about Wall-E making boxes.
It was well made
The music editing needs work, some of the starts, stops, and places where music is and isn't are awkward.
nice, but
I think maybe it's too fast. There's no stops, I mean, there should be that necessary time you need to absorb the expressions, the breathing time. ^^
Other that that, it's pretty cool.
Ukinojoe responds:
Yeah, definitely true. It was only supposed to be 1 minute, and I was already over 1:20 so I tried to speed some parts up.
Classy
Well done, quite funny and true to the characters