this gave me a seizer
Reviews for "The Big Green Button"
i decided to stop clickinng cuz i don't wanna be a squid
Another One
Although its been done a million time this one is pretty good, definately in the top 5
Greenfrost6 responds:
Yep, I'll try to be more creative next time. Thanks for the review.
Hmmmmmm
~ Animation/Graphics ~
No problem here at all. Very simple, but the button looked very good. I liked how it gave way when you were clicking it like a real button. No critiquing on any art or graphics at all.
~ Story/Content ~
Perhaps the idea isn't original, but to be honest no idea ever anymore is original because it's all been done before, so marking down on not being original almost seems a bit idiotic in my opinion.
I think it's more how you approach the the submission even if the idea isn't original and to be honest this is the best one of these submissions I have ever seen.
There was a lot of humor and I laughed throughout a lot of it. I really liked the part where it made you think you were going to start all over from the beginning, but it kept going and laughed at you. I really did fall for it and I'm sure many others did too.
~ Audio ~
I think the parts where you used audio sounded great. I would have liked to see a little bit more audio used in this though. Perhaps something like a voice for all of the clicks so people don't get so bored or have to read the whole thing. If you didn't want to do that then you could at least put on some nice ambient music and have it loop throughout the entire thing, changing if it was necessary in certain parts.
~ Overall ~
Yes it's not an original idea, but the way that you approached it was original and funny. I think audio was the only real thing to improve on. Other than that a decent job all around.
~ Review Request Club ~
It's hard to come up with anything new
Button-flashes are pretty old so it's really hard to come up with something new. I liked those "we are experiencing technical difficulties" bit, those where funny. But I felt you used it once too often. First time it was funny, second time it was still funny, third time it was pretty mediocre.
I also didn't like how many times you made use of the "empty frames" where there was no text beneath the button.
The last thing I didn't like was how long it was. But on the other hand, those button games HAVE to be that long, I guess.
Anyway, it was a good attempt, but I don't think I will ever like those kind of games.
{ Review Request Club }