Reviews for Rwd: 023 Silent Night

[mo4form]

not impressed

I know it is supposed to be a short clip/spam or whatever but its certainly not what I expected from you guys. And no, I'm not giving it a low score because its considered a bash on christians, well mainly because everybody hates them (yes I am an anti-christ. hang me.)

PS: and calling me a fag makes YOU the fag,gay is not an insult specially if its used on a guy who isn't gay.. lemme put it this way; if you call a girl-who is clearly a lady-"guy" it doesn't make her a guy or a dyke, it makes you a weird fag. lol.

RadicalWrongDoers responds:

Just say it... you're not angry, you're disappointed...

About the whole fag thing, you're silly and not very correct.
And yes, Hans completely meant that you are a homosexual when he said that, you specifically.

[smi1ey]

lol @ christians who are offended.

I'm a Christian, and I have a message to other Christians who are whining about this toon:

If you are offended by jokes about Christianity, DON'T VISIT NEWGROUNDS. In fact, I would also recommend not listening to the radio, watching TV, or generally leaving your house for anything. Don't give a cartoon a zero because you were offended by it.

I'm giving this a 5 because the animation was good, but it wasn't very funny IMO, and a bit too over the edge for my taste.I'm not gonna be a hypocryte and bash this even though I'm browsing a site that is filled with garbage that is much worse.

[rickxxown]

Nice animation,

The animation was nice, nice styles here and there but the whole concept and/or "idea", I guess you could call it an idea, is pretty tense. Speaking from an open mind, yea, sure the flash was kind of funny, quirky animation of Mary giving birth to Jesus and Jesus having a beard as a baby made me chuckle but seriously, thinking about how people base their lives or just have strong faith in such a subject, this animation was pretty out-of-context.. something that shouldn't really be submitted since yea it is funny to many but many others find it just as offensive as funny so next time just think about that. No I'm not hating on this but just looking at it from another view.

I'm going to give this a 5/10 because like I said, it was good but the concept was, I shouldn't use ofensive but since I'm having trouble finding a better word, offensive to others. I won't be voting on this so hopefully this 5 (rating) won't ruin your score.

Thanks,

Rickxxown

RadicalWrongDoers responds:

You know what a critique doesn't do?
He doesn't go "Well I thought it was great, but I heard someone two rows behind me saying it was shit... so I guess it's shit, I don't know..."

BAD RICK! BAD!

[LazyKakashi]

kinda insulting...

I gave it a 4, just because the part at the end made me chuckle :(

[RJDRipper]

Oo what

uuum Oo