Great!
I really enjoyed playing this one. The idea is simplistic, yet it takes a bit of skill to do it well. In that way, it is similar to fishing. I loved the James the Zebrafish cameo, thought that was cute. One of the only problems I had though, I would end up reeling too fast because of a problem with my mouse. It's not blamed on you, but it seems like using keys to reel in would make for more of a challenge. For instance, alternating left and right to reel in. Great game, can't wait to see the next.
-Skater