Good!
Nice! I liked it, but it was anoying that is was not the same axe for every one of them, then it would have realy been "pass the axe"
Reviews for ""Pass The Axe" Collab"
Hamalo responds:
Yeah, we kinda thought of that half way through and if I tried to edit all the axe it would mess up the parts because the axes were different sizes etc. If I ever do a collab like this again, I'll make sure everyone uses the same thing
Pretty Good
Ahh, i hate reviewing collabs because either you review the whole thing, which means its inconsistant, or each individual piece. :/
But overall it was pretty good, some were better than others, by alot. But they all seemed to fit together nicely. I liked the variation in ideas throughout the collab, so that it wasnt just an axe killing people all the way through. I particularly liked the Axe Body Spray, the Sprite Tree Stump and the Ness ones.
The graphics were good throughout, they varied though. Some were done very well, some were done horrendously. But id average them all around 7. Some of the stick ones were pretty good as well. And i liked the fact that Sprites, Sticks and Realistic graphics were all used in the collab. The backrounds werent too bad either and the collab showed a broad range of colours. :P
The animation throughout the collab was pretty good, smooth enough throughout. I didnt have any problems with it. The sound was alright, i didnt particularly like the song used, as its not my style. But it fit with it well enough. One scene had characters talking, but they were drowned out by the music. Id advise against voice acting in one track collabs.
Overall it was a pretty good collab, nice work guys. I saw varied levels of style and skill and most were very good. You should make another. Nice work.
Graphics - 7
Animation - 8
Sound - 6
[Review Request Club]
NIce collab
I quite enjoyed it, loved the varying art styles.
Graphically it was a bit hit and miss. Things seemed to work well all together but singly some of them were quite a bit below the standard of the rest. Still liked it, some of them were very good. And I really like how there was multi input between all the collabers. And the menu looked great aswell.
The sound was perfect, a great choice of song. Was funny aswell.
Everything seemed to work fine, really liked all the added extras. Quite well done, had about another movies worth of stuff in there. Really good. Overall a very nice collab, no major complaints. :D
=Review Request Club=
MMFWKCL
I love it. One Helluva collab for Juggalos world-wide. Can't wait for another.
Next time, try another song. Ka-Boom is good. As is Hurt Myself. Make me smile a wickid crooked killer clown grin my friends.
Hamalo responds:
I WOULD but seeing as this was the pass the axe collab I thought that this song would fit. Glad to see a lot of other juggalos on newgrounds...I've already gotten about 8 juggalos commenting, thats more than I thought were on here.
MMFCL
Needs a few tweaks, but overall good.
I'd say that the major issue with the collab in itself is the static that loads up on some of the vocals and indeed the music. If you sorted out the quality issues, it would certainly improve the flash a great deal.
The other thing that I've got an issue with is the wide ranging scale of actual talent levels for the authors. Some are superb, while others have only just learnt how to draw decent stick-figures. Quantity doesn't always equal quality, so maybe this is the kick up the arse that some of the collaberators need, but perhaps you need to consider trimming the final edit, just to give us more quality, overall.
I think that you can go far, as animators and I'll look forward to your next projects - collabs or no.
[Review Request Club]