Good animation. That's it
I want to preface my comment by saying that the animation was pretty good. Better than your typical flash cartoon at the very least. That said...the humor that you included just wasn't any good. It was bottom-of-the-barrel style of humor that you can get from any generic low brow television show. I honestly did not even crack a grin, it was just not at all funny.
I was happy to see an Earthbound reference, but...most of the Nintendo bits you poke fun at have nothing to do with the actual games they parody, but LOL RANDOM XD humor. Which isn't funny.
I think if you worked a little harder this could be better. I'm personally shocked this has been rated so high. Ahhh, as is Newgrounds.