00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

corentingoo just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "Insurgo"

"Not bad, but in need of improvement"

I cant see the incredible parallels between this and tower of goo people keep talking about. Small fundamental differences make a huge difference on the end product. They are both tower builders, but have a lot of different functionality.

My issue is the "flex" or "stretch" in the girders. I realize making them all stiffer will require more number crunching and thusly CPU power, but as is its just lacking - no material used in construction anywhere has either a coefficient of expansion or a k constant anywhere near as high as whats seen here.

If all the materials had the same "stretch" per unit of length, creating a tower with more advanced nodes would add strength, just like bracing does. Making more diagonal braces would distribute the given force and distribute it across mode points, reducing the overall flex of the tower. As it is, the same force is increased - building a simple triangle acts just as strong as one thats been bolstered in 5 different directions.

Also, the comment of "girders on the pylons are 5 times stronger" - that also should never happen. Steel beams attached to the ground are no stronger than those in the air. Why have them be special? And more importantly, as something like that is critical to performance - why not mention that somewhere in the intro or rules?

Again, it is a good effort as something to goof around with for a few minutes, but the number crunching behind the system is pretty crude - household materials like popsicle sticks or drinking straws would offer better structural performance to the "girders" used here.

VoidSkipper responds:

Um, did you not read the text you clicked to play? It reads "PLAY THIS GAME!". Game. It's not supposed to be realistic, coefficients of expansion and k constants were not even considered - in fact, the pylons aren't real. Only the bolts are! The pylons stretch because they're just a representation of the theoretical spring that holds the bolts together!

Why make the pylons connected the bottom five times stronger? Because that makes it more fun and allows for further expansion, jackass.

Now you tell me, honestly, would you really like to see a perfectly accurate building simulation built in flash, which, due to the interpretive nature of the flash player and the fact that graphics and calculations are both shared by the cpu, would run at about five frames per second once you have more than three pylons on the screen, or would you like to play a game?

By all means, though, go and play with popsticks and drinking straws if that's what you prefer.

not interesting enough

to much credit i hate how u donno how much your next peice of metal is goin to be so it will never come out stable and it doesn't really make me wanna play more

VoidSkipper responds:

I don't really know what you mean... I think you may be playing it wrong.

this is a piece of crap

I didn't like the conditions I spent so much time doing everithing i could 2 make it stand and i deleted 1! piece and i lost!!

VoidSkipper responds:

Please read the instructions and check your IQ before reviewing.

i dont like it

there should be a fun mode like sandbox and difficultys and in sandbox there should be no time and the pylons would stay there for like 3 secs before falling i hope you can do that in the sequel. P.S there is a glich that you can just keep on building it up and it will not fall and anothere where when you press the space bar for the special it stays on the freeze time for like 5 mins

VoidSkipper responds:

That's not a glitch.

nothing new

look, if you want to hit the top, get inspiration from animators like st1k and coolioniato. They have hit the top. and I'm being leinent with the 4 rating, it's like a 3.2.try harder next time. oh and by the way. insurego remix is a lot better.

VoidSkipper responds:

Hey there. I'm not an animator, in case you didn't notice. I'm a programmer.

Insurgo remix is mine as well. Glad you enjoyed it.

[EDIT: Just so you know, Insurgo Remix is -exactly- the same game, just with rebranded graphics and sound. I reserve the right to take your opinion with a handful of salt.]

I'm somewhat vexed by your "3.2", though. Please PM me the constructive criticism that this review is lacking. I do hope it contains something other than "you are not St1k or Coolioniato", because that is somewhat obvious.