Reviews for Seige!

[fuffka]

koo.

kool, pretty good for a first time. i gave it a 4/5.

deado000 responds:

cheers, i only got it a couple of days ago, watched a couple of tutorials, then just experimented.

thanks a lot for the review =]

[gnome42]

well..it was bad.. but good for your first i guess

it wasnt real
when youre making a movie you gotta think "what would it really be like?"
and then animate based on that

like. the cannonballs just bounced off. and when a cannonball bumped the other, it rolled.. heavy cannonballs arent supposed to roll because they get bumped :P
and the castle falling wasnt too realistic.
the castle fell, and just slid over the tops of the cannonballs
when it should have crumbled o_O
but yeah since you were only experimenting with tweens
good job with those

deado000 responds:

yeah, i suppose i dont have any thought of weight of the balls, but yeah it was just an experiment and it was my 1st thing to make.

thanks a lot for the tips and review =]

[ETN]

...Kinda slow

Yah... I don't know what else to say.. except maybe to only tween for bout 3-5 frames... but i'm not sure how many it went thru so i can't really say much 'cept that it's just a little too slow

deado000 responds:

yeah, well i set it to 30fps and i was half way through making when i changed it, so i had to extend to frames, but i must have gone a little too far

thanks a lot for the review =]

[PhilOnDez]

Pointless

As I'm sure you know there wasn't really a point to it. However, solely from an animation standpoint, it wasn't bad. In that regard I'd give it a 7-8. If you make a movie with this much quality, or perhaps even better, I'd really like to see it

deado000 responds:

thanks a lot for the review =]

[Gyojiro]

Lemme put it this way...

As someone who is worse inf lash than anyone else, this is good, compared to anything I can do... However, try to restrict your submissions on Newgrounds to things you positively love... I realize you want people to tell you how it is, but this is just too short, and lacks a plot to be put on the portal. However, your art style is quality, and with a little more effort and time, you'll do just fine!

deado000 responds:

thanks, i just need to think of a plotline, then work around it.

thanks a lot for the compliments and review =]