Sweet! Except...
Well, the animation was much better than I expected it to be. (You did belittle yourself a little there, so I was uhh... wondering if it was how you said it would turn out to be, but it turned out to be pretty darn good.)
The fairies were cutely drawn, and you could see the happiness that they exuberantly expressed. Even though you said it didn't look that great, it looked pretty well to me, especially since this is your first submission.
Storyline... ehh, I'm going to be honest with ya. It felt very awkward. I mean, you gave us that huge happy/fun feeling and you spread it throughout your flash movie, but as the dark forest came, it became immediately dark and horrific. I was absolutely shocked how fast and sharp the environment changed and it gave it a very uncomfortable mood. Now if the whole movie was dark to begin with, that would of been understandable, but the shift was too sudden, and the new story that arose from the dark area wasn't given enough time to fully develop, causing that feeling of unanswered questions and what not.
In a more personal perspective, when I see happy/cheerful things, I like them to stay happy/cheerful, so that's why it got awkward when the sad/dark effect just kicked in out of nowhere. Not to say that this was the specific reason why you got downgraded in score a little, but it's just a little personal thing of mine.
Like others have said, it's kind of unorganized, and needs to be checked up on a little. Give characters and storylines more time to develop (I.E. Make longer flash movies so we can truly see what the characters are like, and the understanding of each specific storyline). You've got a great start at Newgrounds with this flash submission, and it seems like it's going to be pretty nice seeing more of you work.
It's always good to see new flash artists come in with their completed flash projects, so I hope to see more soon. Make the next one a bit longer, or create a series for us to watch. Either way should turn out great. Hopefully though, you'll make it more fine-tuned and everything. :D
- Nondo