lord...tough, tough to judge.
first off this is by far the hardest battle i've had to judge to date. you guys both put on a great show. you guys got a really though beat with an 90's swing style that kinda forced it to have a happier feel that you both adapted to really well.
I listened through a few times, each time focusing on the individual categories.
there wasn't much wordplay in this thing, just a shitload of punches. so narrowed down the most important categories the best I could.
Delivery and flow: 10-10. Both of you guys have got skill, and both of you guys had some moments that you fell off the beat and forced some syllables. Gasmasq had a more complex rhyme scheme. Whatever disadvantage ICON suffered from that though, he made up with more charisma.
Content: 10-9 Gasmasq.
There were some decent personals, but there was plenty of filler for both of them. I didn't feel like there were any real knockout punches in this battle, it was more like a rap marathon, which can be cool too. Gas flipped the mom line, but for a little bit too long, I thought. The rahrahrahrahrah was funny and well delivered for ICON. What It really came down to for me was that I didn't think Icon's punches held as much weight as his flow and charisma. Saying he looks like Lilo and Stich and someone from All That brings more attention to the fact that you watch kid shows than it harms him. I agreed with the review that said the Japan line was forced and uncomfortable. You have the entire world to choose from lyrically, and it may not be the best thing to take a current crisis and make light of it within a week or so of it's happening for a battle rap. I'm not taking off points for that, I just think it's a poor decision.
In summary, I have to go with Gasmasq in a very, VERY close battle between two battlers who represent some of the best of what this competition has to offer. Good luck to both of you guys.