was good
refer to up place
Reviews for "Space Fortress Macross"
Not a bad piece of work.
The mecha was nicely done, the people were okay when they weren't moving. The voice acting was more than passable, with only two voices being any sort of annoying. Small discrepancy over how different people pronounce Macross, but that's to be expected. Nice usage of classic music and SFX for that whole Macross feel. Wasn't quite sure what to think at first when there were voice clips from the original Breetai, and then new English acting, but it wasn't a problem. Nice job.
MedMapGuy responds:
I was afraid too that the transition would be jarring when I used the original Britai's voice and then it segues into my voice track, but in the end it wasn't bad. Limited animation is all I can achieve at the moment...
Ok, dick move on your part.
I don't see why you have to give his review any crap. He was right, it is nothing no. And I'm pretty darn sure, you traced half of the drawings in this flash. In some parts, you can see the spots where you forgot to seperate the lines. It is good, to a certain extent. Maybe I will give you the benefit of the doubt, and you didn't trace. But the whole thing was choppy. No smooth movement at all, and I can tell already that you think WAY to highly of your flash. It's good. Thats it. Not great. Not wonderful. It's good.
MedMapGuy responds:
I understand the performance issues, and I'll try to optimize it in the future.
Just to set the record straight for all you naysayers... I hardly traced. Check this gallery, if you're still not convinced:
http://blog.com/photos/galler y/10860/
I hope this sets the record straight for all you naysayers. BTW, if you like Lesboformers, then that's no problem. I like that stuff as much as the next guy!
Lets see...
The graphics were really good and had a greats details but this anime thing, ets, airplanes that transform into robots is just not original. Maybe if you have used ur talent to creat something really new, it would make my eyes shine and roll but this one didnt. Well maybe its just me. Keep working.
MedMapGuy responds:
Here's to a guy who found Lesboformers was a classic.
I don't know whether I should take this seriously.
Great Work.
Very nice work, brilliant art, good animation. Another MedMapGuy Classic. I hope your get your justly deserved FrontPage and award :).
Nicw work.