Not bad
I kinda liked it. There was a different make a pumpkin thing today, if the maker of that one and you got together you could make a GREAT pumpkin maker.
Reviews for "Make A Pumpkin!"
Cute concept, but it needs more depth
This is a cute concept for a flash, and I always appreciate a "dress-up game" that doesn't involve nudity to bring in ratings. Unfortunately, aside from the pumpkiny goodness, this flash is a bit lacking.
You had the correct set-up for the stereotypical game of this genre, and I honestly think that was your biggest mistake. When people carve a pumpkin, they prefer that it be a unique reflection of their personality. By giving them pre-determined options, you're making it easier on the designers, but you're also DRASTICALLY limiting their creativity. Being able to design your own eyes, mouths, etc. would be a nice addition, though you'd have to find a way to make sure it didn't just become "MS Paint : The Super Flash Version". Perhaps allowing people to draw an outline of a shape and have the program automatically fill it in.
Your song was generic and forgettable, which is just fine for a short-looped song like that, since it doesn't get stuck in your head. So ... that was actually a compliment.
To sum things up, your flash is, right now, only mediocre. More options, more freedom, and more little pre-made pumpkin shapes would definately help push your score higher.
Dissapointing
You could have done way better, did you even try? Three year olds could draw better than that, I would think if you're going to do something for other people to see you'd want it done well, but I guess not.
K
^^Good Points^^
There is quite a variety of items to choose from in this dress up game. You had a few different pumpkin types which is nice too.
^^Needs Improving^^
Well, the graphics really weren't good in this game. Everything looked really sloppy and there wasn't much detail or shading. I think you could also have some music that is more in the spirit of chrismas. Really, I'm not liking the music in this game.
it was good but...
the artwork was kinda bad, and the music was annoying. it was a good idea, just not put togethor too well.