Different, but great
I think this one of the most unique things you have ever submitted. What's really great is how you didn't have a narrator or any dialogue for this one. It kind of makes you realize how stupid the people of the town are in these stories. You have proven that there's a guy who can control things and you double cross him? I should have known there wouldn't be a happy ending here. Again, I don't see how this is comedy.
I like how it had the feel of an old silent movie. I have only seen a few of those and they have been great. While it wasn't around Halloween, it certainly had the feel of something creative. You should know that all the girls in these cartoons never come out right. It makes me realize, that I don't think you've ever done one with a boy.