that was awful please don't make another
i'm afraid you have digraced the name of madness, good day to you sir!
Reviews for "Star Wars: Rebel Alliance"
Bad
Im sorry but this was bad, i expected more from the madness series. I just thought it was boring
cool
its awesome... i just love this....great job...i love the whole madness series!!!!1 keep up the great work....but u should have writen the body count like in other movies.....
hmmmmmmmmm
ok i quite liked it i must admit even if the animaton was a bit crappy (wadda tha matter with u did you lose intrest whilst making it??????????) i enjoyed it. overall it was an ok piece good story line i liked the charectors and very good use of music maybe it cud be tidied up round the edges thou but good effort dude
pretty good for what it is (a madness-SW crossover
Stuff people said below me, and why they are wrong ^_^
_______________________________________________
1) A few major things wrong... Hoth is not a freekin desert, its an ice planet.
He wasn't trying to use hoth. There were other battles besides hoth that happened on planets...
2) AT-AT can not be destroyed by X-wings
AT-ATs can indeed be destroyed by X-wings. That's like saying a bomber cant destroy a tank. At Hoth, they didn't use X-Wings to destroy the AT-ATs because the transports needed escorts
3) Lightsabres too long.
And how can you say the light sabers are too long? Did you measure a "real" light saber, then measure the little light sabers in this submission and scale it? If so, GET A LIFE!
4) You mixed up the Rebel's aircraft: X-Wing, for an imperial aircraft.
No, he didn't. You may have gotten confused. In the scene where the Jedi is traveling to the Rebel base on the desert planet, he is very closely followed by the Darth Maul-ish Sith, who is traveling in a sith craft.
5) Your story had no plot. What was the Jedi trying to steal?
Plans for the Death Star. Did you not see the beginning when Emporer Palpatine was showing Darth Maul the plans, then Darth Maul put them in the glowy thingie?
___________________________
Anywho, on to my actual review! It was good. I do agree it was a little rushed, but it was an interesting story. It didn't have the traditional madness-style...well, madness. However, for a Star Wars-Madness crossover, very well done.
erixs responds:
Thank you, well argued all and all. You understood my ideas even if their maybe were well hidden!