What the hell dudes...
I am really torn on this one. For starters, at the least I'm going to say you did quite a good job with the animation process... including ripping other, pre-existing characters already internationally renowned in ways I'm not sure you'll ever be... but I'm going to skip that little beginning of an insult and just say: substance. Life and death will not ever (provided there iis a just and loving god which is already called into question based on this being put out) hinge on the chat-lives of a group of 12-15 year old kids. Just because you think an experience is vivid doesn't make it analogous to every-day life, nor does it create a situation in which I think any normal person is going to feel as though they have just emoted... short of anger and hatred for chat forums around the globe filled with people whose biggest struggle in life is getting rid of spammers.
This is not getting blammed for animation or sound... this is getting blammed for being utterly pointless. You are the Kevin Costner of NG my friend... spending a lot of time on something that is bound to amount to nothing everyone else... and this is your waterworld. *sigh*... just cause it looks pretty don't make it worth a damn.