meh
i didn't think much of it, sorry. good efforts though
Reviews for "Clone-a-ma-tron"
Interesting
It was a funny flash, I liked it. Maybe next time have more than stick figures and maybe a background. I liked the music, but it was the only sound.
i liked it.
very nice indeed. Although the graphics were bad (no background, stick figures) i dont think that a movie like this really needs excellent art work. I find watching stick figures much more entertaining (if they have faces) because they are much easier to animate, and therefore they show more emotion, and can do more things.
but yeh, graphics COULD have been better. Sound was good; i liked that song.
Also, the movie itself had a really cool idea. so overall, some nice work. but next time, why not add some sound effects in there, eh?
overall score: 6/10
(THE THUMB: UP!)
I have to agree with the reviewer before me
Although, the movie had a great start, the movie stopped off in a weird place. It could have been funnier, also as the other reviewer noted the characters weren't really walking through (you should give more time between walking from left end and to the right end of the machine). Funny movie, although you probably could have done better.
Pathetic...
I have seen so many flashes that are so much better than this get blammed everyday.
To the first reviewer: Giving a flash like this a high score because it's by a beginner(?) at flash is just stupid. You vote on the movie, not the artist(?).
The good:
1) You started out okay with the gags.
2) The animation is decent.
The Bad:
1) The music.
2) It got really old, really fast.
3) It was done with basically stick figures. You get low on graphics for that.
4) None of the characters actually looked like they entered the machine after they became groups of 4+.
5) The smiling and waving bugged the crap out of me the first time. The second sent me into a homicidal rage.
I saw a lot of really high reviews for this thing. I checked a lot of profiles, and none of the high reviews were over level 3. Most were levels 1 and 2. Even the ones who have a "dark" alignment. People, try honestly evaluating these things. A four on this is extremely generous. It deserves a one or two. It's honestly not as bad as a lot of things submitted into the portal, but it's definitely far from great.
To the artist: Good job for getting it through judgement. I would probably have blammed this with a one, myself. The idea was good, but it needs a lot of work. 2/3 of the movie is just of them running around and around through the cloning machine. If you came up with a few more gags, I would give a much higher review. I checked out your other flash movie, which I must admit was much better. It warrants a 3/4. However, I still am amazed at the 8.55/10.00 it got in reviews... several movies on the top 50 had barely higher, and a couple had worse. Anyway, good luck on future submissions.
To all: If it seems I am a bit harsh, well, I probably am. Too many low-quality flash movies are making it through judgement as it is. I just do my best to clean it up, and try to get only the best movies through.