wait a second...
the timings spead up slightly but I'd say this is exactly the same as the advent children version with a few different notes here and there. I'd rate 9 but I can't shake my suspicions of you copying this song. 4
Reviews for "FF7-Those Who Fight (Pian"
DJ-Nightmare responds:
if u dont believe me i could even send u the fl file of all the notes.
I Call BS
There is absolutely no change in dynamics or tempo the whole song and you claim you played this by hand?
This version of the battle theme is off of the Final Fantasy VII Piano Collection, of which I have both the album and the actual sheet music. I've been playing playing piano for 17 years, 13 of which with lessons, and I've played this song out of the book. It sounds like you tried to translate the recorded version of this song to midi by ear, because many notes are incorrect. The tempo is too perfect to be human, and a trained pianist would never play it so rigidly, anyway, particularly the middle part which is supposed to be more gentle. Lack of dynamics could just be because the keyboard isn't pressure sensitive, so I'll give you that one. If you did play this by hand, it was done very slowly with a metronome and sped up later, though there's still a heavy reverb on the notes, so I doubt it, unless you added it later.
Therefore I think your claim that this isn't sequenced (MIDI) is BS.
You get a 3 since copying this by ear would be difficult. I'm assuming you didn't have the sheet music in front of you when you put wrong notes in.
DJ-Nightmare responds:
No offense. Its not bs. Because i never wrote that i played it. I wrote that i put down the notes. If midi means that i used a producing system then yes it is midi and i apologize for the misleading "Author Comment." But as for sheet music. I did use sheet music. 7 Pages of sheet music to be exact. I myself have been playing piano for 15 years so its not like im a noob at the real thing. I just wanted to hear how this would sound on a piano and since im nowhere near good enough to learn this myself i figured i would make it on Fruity Loops. So I'm sorry if you took it as if I meant that I played this myself. If you really can play this I would appreciate if you could send me a video of you playing it. I would love to see your skills as a pianist.
DJ-Nightmare
You say every note was put down by you, but...
...This sounds exactly like a sped up version on "Those who Fight" from the Piano collections of FFVII. I'm not impressed.