amazing
amazing rendition of a classic composition by one of thebest composers man has ever known
i love the twist you put on it, def. adds your own style
great job dude, if the AP had more tracks like this, NG would be a much better place
Reviews for "2'29''"
Haggard responds:
"great job dude, if the AP had more tracks like this, NG would be a much better place"
Haha, I'm not so sure about that. I think people would rather listen to something they could actually hear. ^^
But as I've responded to an earlier review, I wanted to see how Users would react to such a submission. Also, I really like 4'33'', the idea behind it. ^^
Quiet...
It's pretty good, but a lot of aspects of this song were just too quiet.
The melodies were, well, quiet, and I couldn't hear them, not to mention the instruments which although fit very, very well with melodies, were actually quite quiet.
The transitions... well, some were too quiet, but the good news is nothing felt wrong in the song, and everything flowed so well. The intro was OK, but similar to the rest of the song, and the ending was actually just as good as the intro, if not a tad too quiet. Oh, and I think you should remove a bit of the silence at the end; there was much too much silence.
The percussion over here was actually quite good, and didn't disrupt the flow of the song. My only concern is that it's just a little, yeah, you guessed it, quiet.
In all, it's an OK song, but needs work concerning the loudness of it. It's just too...................... quiet. Still, you get a 10/10 for effort! ^^.
10/10
5/5
Download - heh, as if :P.
-Review Request Club-
Haggard responds:
Lol, nice review, thanks.
Yeah, I agree it's too quiet, but if I turn up the volume there will be statics, which kinda ruin the song. :P
is it me or can anyone else not hear anything?
i can hear everything else on NG and my volume is high as welll, and i dont hear anything at all when this plays for now a 5..
Haggard responds:
You should look up 4'33'' on Wikipedia. ;)
3.77!?
scores of 4 and 3!? THIS IS MADNESS! Those were some of the most wonderful chord progressions I've ever heard! Great job at giving this remix your own *awesome* personal flair, I dont see anything wrong with this. well, i guess it was a bit quiet tho, but it works!
Haggard responds:
Thanks! :)
"well, i guess it was a bit quiet tho,"
You know, I really had to laugh at this sentence! :D
Enh.
There are a few bits of noise in the audio. I dunno if that's the mic hitting off something else or what.
I would have expected you to just leave the mic unplugged for this!
Regarding the piece - whether the sped-up version or the original - I guess the most interesting part is in the reactions. Sitting in a concert hall, I'd be interested to wee how others were reacting - specially on the opening night.
4:33 seems similar to Duchamp's urinal, which created the field of modern art. Uninspiring in and off itself, but its mere presence sent shockwaves through the field, though not necessarily changing it for the better.
Haggard responds:
"I would have expected you to just leave the mic unplugged for this!"
I don't even own a mic! :P