Your game need rhythm !
It's so slow. Actions take so much time !
Graphics are ok and it can be a good game, but with so slow movements you can't have a fast pace reaction and funny play !
Watch films about pirates and see how the fights are shown ;) !

This really needs AI. Even though it doesn't it is still a really fun game!

The concept isn't bad, but the motions need to be sped up a lot because as it is now it's just too easy to always block your opponent or end up in a draw.

Game needs work for starters making the screen smaller will help improve the game because right now you can't see everything. When a player blocks the an attack the attack still goes through nor does a player seem to take any damage.

Not bad. Has plenty on potential.
Slight improvements could be made so that swords touch each other when blocking. Reaction time could also be lowered so that I don't have to wait a couple of seconds before each hit registers.