This video mocks one specific review, one made by Doktillia on your 'Foany' animation, which predates Dot Dot Dot by a couple of years at least.
Graphics: I've seen Fat Badger as well, and he just throws whatever into his flash and mashes it all together, whereas you keep a consistent, if not surreal art style that doesn't rely too much on existing assets or motion tweens. I'm not saying Fat Badger is better than you, it's more like he primarily focuses on spam.
Style: Germaine talked, but Foamy's voice was gibberish that later goes distorted as he mutates.
Sound: Could be annoying + gay on purpose.
Violence: A maggot crawled out of Foamy's eye and his head turned into a vagina, and that was 'a little violence'.
Interactivity: There are PLAY and REPLAY buttons, that's about it. This was before Movies and Games were split into two categories.
Humor: The joke is that Foamy's face becomes super creepy. I guess Doktillia had a point. I will point out one thing, the movie was short.
I will keep in mind that this was very early in your career and your second animation on Newgrounds, of course it's not going to be refined.
To summarise, what pretty much happened is that a n00b was talking shit to a not-so n00b.