Cool

Its gets more piratey at about 0:48 but it still doesn't remind me too much of pirates.
Nevertheless its a cool tune and 5/5 for you

Well it reminded me of something.

The main music and intro sounds alot like the super paper mario theme.

the maestro says all

it isn't really my idea of piratey. still very good though.

Impressive

yahr, them pirates be screwed says I, for they be goin to the dark caves of the great sea cackle woman of the sea... who cackles.

I joke, I jest.

It has an awesomely dark atmosphere, which I absolutely loved. That rattle you used, was a pretty neat effect, doesn't scream "pirate" but does serve its purpose.

I didn't quite like the Accordian you used, it didn't sound very accordiany.

Nice choir though, sounds pretty neat.

The melody was awesome, I'm all about the melody.

When you extended that "aaah" for nearly ten seconds, I felt that was a bit much.

4/5 from me PunkerFish, keep them coming.