Ehh...

I thought it was boring. Nothing really happens. People have been using "soothing" as an excuse for boring for ages, but I don't buy into that crap. People generally don't listen to music to go to sleep, they listen to it to be interested in it, and interested is the exact opposite of how I feel towards this song. I don't suppose it's much worse than all the crap I've heard on this site though. At least it's not electronic, meaning, I can listen to it without my ears feeling like they're bleeding from talentless people creating electronic techno loops in Fruity Loops, so you have that going for you.

You can call some elevator companies though, I'm sure they'll be more than willing to please their customers while they ride with your music.

Fantastic

This is a lovely waltz. The performance and recording could be a little better, but one should be careful not to judge a composition by the performance. If you wanted to expand on this you could write a new section in a different key, and then transition back to the first part, but with more elaboration. It's fine as is, though. I gave you a 5.

Delightful

Very soothing, easy on the ear, and well put together.

Peaceful

The music feels like it should lull anyone to sleep. Kep up your awesome work!