Very good indeed! Let's start out.
Story: 5/5 Fine Fine, not the worst not the best. The islands looked like Haiti, the Dominican Republic, and a few others I don't want to name.
The funny thing is how the captain wanted to be a pirate, met pirates, didn't kill the pirate captain, and almost died because of that.
The map maker was kind of an asshole though, at least split the treasure.
The blue captain was an idiot, 50/50 should be what was given.
Graphics: 5/5 Basic flash, not to bad not to good. Just right. The frame rate could have been better.
Fighting: 4/5 Not very good, it looked like they were playing around and not fighting.
They should have had a fighting stance, and more thrustful sword fighting.
Length of movie: 4/5 It could be better.
When this was made: 10/5 2002, shows real skill.
I'm sure you have Improved your skills drastically.
Good luck in your movies!