Short and rather easy as most Carmel games, but I like the detective twist where you must connect dots and make a deduction better then simple adventure game. Still I find it weird that the dead man holds a book in his hand and was placed in safe with not dropping it, so deduction about library is obvious but strange. The other two deductions had solid enough reasons. I give this 2.5 stars as for an adventure game and add a star for the Detective topping.