this game suck and it doest have not Watson I mean have they even read the books
Reviews for "Sherlock Holmes 2"
The first Sherlock Holmes game was one of the best games from Carmel / Deathtiger0. After the good first game this second part was a disappointment.
The first game was a proper detective game. Anyone was suspect and in the end it was up for the player to deduce who was guilty. In this game the Holmes tells who is guilty in place of the player taking away half the fun, making this just a standard short and easy Carmel adventure game.
Also the plot doesn't make sense. The guilty guy has forced himself to live in a hidden compartment for his whole life or risk demonstrating that no murder ever happened. He should have killed his handmaiden or some hobo and then frame the fire alarm guy. Doing that on himself was stupid, now he cant even go to shop and leave his house. Also doing a thing like this merely because of rejected love 20 years ago is rather stupid.
How to crack open the safe at the crime scene: find the two pieces of ripped paper. There should be figures scribbled on it. Count their legs. That's the code.
Solid holmes game loved it nice story soundtrack and design
I loved it, but why you change the appeareance of the first Holmes? I mean, I also liked this version, but is like when they replace the actor in a movie's sequel. It feels weird. And the music... I don't know, it just doesn't fit. It's a classic PI song, but I don't feel like "Sherlock style", ya know? The rest, proper good game from Death Tiger0. You know I'm a fan.