Well I found this game soon after it came to Newgrounds and I keep coming back to check on my favorite stories. In my book that means this is a success. I love how my decisions can influence an entire story and it seems like the authors might enjoy the challenge of it as well. I also love the originality of it and the diversity of the story selection.
I give you 5 stars because as the game is now, it's pretty perfect. With the small selection of stories it's easy to find the one I'm looking for, but if it grows (and I'm hoping it does) then I think a search bar would come in handy.