Reviews for Fullmetal Arithmetist

[neolunar12]

Pretty good.

For only four days of Flash experience, the animations were pretty good. The pacing could have been just a bit quicker, though.

On the whole rating argument thing, I think that it's true that if you couldn't do any better, it's slightly hypocritical to criticize him for the animation quality. However, at the same time, the whole reason reviews exist is to provide constructive criticism for the author so that the next time he makes an animation, he can produce one of a better quality. I say, why argue over it at all? BoobMarley, just listen to the legitimate criticism to help you do better next time, and reviewers, if you didn't like the animation, tell him exactly what you didn't like about it and how he could improve it rather than simply stating "it sucked".

There, i've pitched my rant to society.

BoobMarley responds:

If the whole reason reviews exist is to provide constructive criticism... the mods have had a whole pile of non-relevant shit to delete on their hands. Starting from day one.

Reviews exist for some people to type "lol", and for jealous and or angry 14 year olds to type "fucking fag. this is gay, you are gay. it's gay that you write mean things back to people that write unintelligent, inflammatory remarks with no critical value to you or incoming viewers. fag".

Sorry you had to hear the truth from a guy who calls himself BoobMarley.

[adjective2100]

FYI

Wow, what kind of logic is that?

I may have never cooked a meal in my life, but if I've eaten in hundreds of restaraunts all over the world, I could be considered a food critic.

The same goes for art, music and film. I don't have to have ever needed to draw anything to know it's crap. I don't have to ever ave played the trumpet to know when it sounds awful.

The same goes for you and your flash animation. If you're not open to critism, you
re an idiot. Thousands of people on this site have seen hundreds of flash animations both and bad. They don't to have ever animated anything to tell you where you need to improve.

Maybe you get off of your high horse and listen to your audience.

BoobMarley responds:

I'm on this high horse for good reason.
Your review is worthless for good reason (hint: where's da grammar at yo?)

[rhythmmaster]

sir....

The animation was bad, as was the story. You didn't deviate from the canon, save for a lame-ass divide by zero joke. And the worst part is that you defend your sorry ass video by being a complete dick.

BoobMarley responds:

3,800 folks disagree. Or are also dicks.

[RayoerRane]

wow

Wow um can you chill out with the fyi part

BoobMarley responds:

No. I'm not a sopping cunt.

[Neoxx66]

Eh...

The music and pacing was slow, it was almost like a serious animation when the concept is meant to be funny. (I think?) So yeah if you're gonna go for a divide by 0 joke you could have made the entire thing a bit more light hearted but it was dark and dramatic despite the silly theme making it seem off putting. For 2 months of flash experience the animation wasn't bad but it did seem a little blocky and some shading or outlines would probably make it look more visually appealing, the style of flat colors makes me think of south park which I'm pretty sure you weren't going for. Also the anatomy seemed a little off, mainly their super thick necks but tiny bodies. So yeah keep up the good work, grats on getting front page and take knowledge from each review even if you claim they are "useless"