Reviews for Lady Noir

[Catalyste]

Not a full 10. A good 8 will do.

The first part sucked. I was about to rate stop the movie altogether, but I remembered the description said 4 stories, so I was waiting for it to happen. Even though the animation needs tons of work, it as a nice twist story-wise.

The second part was amazing. I loved the animation and the way you gave her the persona of a ruthless animal. I think this helped set the standard for her character during this collab. Wonderful work.

The third part.....dude, when you play Floyd you just win. So thanks for showing us your dapper side with this bit. Even though all the male faces were basically the same, the whole thing still gave me the sense that I was watching some British crime movie....Layercake, Two Guns...yes, I enjoyed those. So thanks for the memories.

The fourth part is a pure female version of Josh Hartnett's character from Sin City; the assassin. lol My complaint about this bit was that the proportions were wrong, namely her legs. One of them was just too fat for a back shot.

Anyway good show! 8/10 because once you get over the first bit, it does become enjoyable to watch.

Thanks!

[ve-chan]

Hm.

First one was bad, second was good, third was good , and 4 th was good

[silverdust87]

EZ with the Floyd XD

I liked the whole collab I didn't know exactly what to expect but great job all of you guys audio and visual

[noahpineapple]

wow

the first part kinda sucked when it came to close-up animation but the 3rd and 4th videos along with the incredably awesome sound track made up for it

[HappyG]

The music made it

The collaboration as a whole was not the best I've seen, there wasn't as much flow as I would've liked and some of the animations seemed rushed.

Zapwadda's input was probably me least favourite and it was a shame that it started the collaboration off.

Denzel-Crocker really showcased great artistic skills and animation fluidity, I was very impressed and would love to see some more of this artist's work.

Keiran-S was very stylised and there were a few things I would've like to have done to improve the overall feel, but the character design was quite good and the concept was also there.

Red Harvest showed great skill in some of the sketches, but lacked continuity. It went from great proportion and beautiful characters to stumpy, out of proportion and rather strange looking in other places and you could see the scenes where more attention was payed.

Over-all though, I thought the sound production and choice of music was fantastic and really lifted the entire piece. It gave variety while still being one and each piece was well chosen.

<3 HappyG