Reviews for Big Bad Uncle

[FightingSeraph]

Not bad, but it needs improvement.

Knox, I would like to say "Welcome Back to NG." Unlike Legendary Frog, your return was needed. However, this needs a bit of improvement and I will have to explain. While I don't mind your blob characters, you could have animated their walk cycles a bit more. On the other hand, comedy doesn't need great animation, just enough to get the point across; and that's the way it should be on Newgrounds. As for the humor, mildly funny and simple. Nothing bad with that because not everything has to be like Rats on Cocaine (Dean Packis rules). However, your character voices need improvement, even though that's part of the joke; just like Eskimo Bob.

What I do like:
-Good image quality
-Mildly funny
-Good animation for clay

What I did not like:
-Voice acting could be better.
-The characters could use better walk and run cycles.

Overall: Knox, here's your seven out of ten. As for future NG submissions, you should do more Newgrounds Deathmatch cartoons; I know plenty of flash cartoonists/voice actors/characters who deserve to be put in the ring.

Knox responds:

well keep in mind that i made this claymaton a year ago haha. i still got like 6-7 more to upload.

[Sufuan]

Very good !

:D that was funny . I like what u do :D the kicking part was great :D

[cseidl1]

Good-looking, fairly intelligent

I had no problem with the undifferentiated characters (that's obviously part of the act) but I do think the story is a little less substantial than I would like it to be. I'm not expecting epic poetry but I didn't find anything surprising. Still, your claymation is great--thanks for sharing.

[FloydianWholigan]

Nothing special...

... but I have to give credit for it being clay-mation. I've always been a very big fan of stop motion and clay.

However, your style is pretty crude- not so much in the animation itself, but there's no real definition or differentiation between the characters. They're all just blue blobs with arms and legs; some a little larger than others, but they're all basically the same. I'd be really impressed if there was more detail to them and their actions.

The major downfall here, though, is just the story and script. In about 5 minutes absolutely nothing happened other than a lot of pointless banter with no punchline. There was just a whole lot of build up for no payoff.

That said, I hope you'll continue to work in this medium. Not many people do stop motion and it's a refreshing change. I can definitely appreciate the amount of time and work that goes into something like this and I'd really like to see a finished product that's worth the time it took for you to produce it as well as the time it took me to watch it.

[BFOverlord]

Eseal is a retarded child.

Newgrounds is the host of a wide array of flash, music, and picture artists. Claymation is just another form of entertainment. I for one did not think this was "unoriginal" mostly because I can probably count on one hand how many claymation submission artists there are. That or you do not know the meaning of the word. Unoriginal is something that lacks originality. If everyone made madness films Newgrounds would suck, I love madness so there is nothing wrong with that series, but for one, Newgrounds is not the "Home" of madness. MadnessCombat.com is the home of madness your cock sucker. Egoraptor also has his own site, and as I recall so does Harry, although I may be wrong. Anyways, point being Eseal, before you act stupid again, take something for what its worth and dont base it off irrelevant series to which Newgrounds is the "Home" of it.

Anyways, this was a funny, and ORIGINAL flash if I do say so myself. I enjoyed the SMOOTH animation and the voice acting was enhanced by the character movements.