Reviews for Farewell... Grandfather

[AlterIre]

beautiful

JosephAS1 responds:

I'm glad that you find this "Beautiful" (:

[brianwonjung]

i love it~ especially the song with those vocal thingy...i don't know what they're called but wow, its very nice :)

JosephAS1 responds:

Thnks you!

those vocal things are called "choirs" indeed :)

[ECFarrell]

I can feel that "Nostalgia" stuff, and you definitely painted the picture of an ocean sunset! While the song seems like it could be leading to something more... profound, I can't say it needs to be changed. Consequently, I just happened to be reading Bioshock Rapture while listening to this song; a more bittersweet mood could not be made.

My condolences for your loss. Your grandfather would be proud.

JosephAS1 responds:

Thanks a lot for your review c:

[Cmdtrigun]

Very ethereal, makes me happy and sad at the same time. I'm sure you grandfather would love this. I sure do.

[MissyZ]

I lost my grandpa last weekend. Yesterday we buried his ashes on a hillside on the first farm he owned underneath a boulder engraved with his name. The hill looks out over the remains of the barn and pastures where he grew up, and out over the prairie fields where he used to raise cattle. Your song makes me remember the view very vividly and break into tears. Thank you for writing something so moving.