Well,
This wasn't as well done as it really could have been. I'm not positive, but I'm guessing that it was done at 12 fps. This could have been compensated for, however, it was not. I'm not saying that this was horrible, however, I don't agree with your other reviewers. You really could have paid way more attention to detail (which is the point of stick flashes, they are supposed to have extreme detail in order to throw off the stereotype of sticks being simple to make). I know, you animated the sticks frame-by-frame. This takes a long time. But, despite the amount of time it probably took you, it should have taken longer. I definitely felt that you missed the point of stick fights and that it was severely underdone, however, I am not, in any way, trying to be discouraging. I think you should take a long time and watch something like the Castle series. This way, you could get some ideas from more detail artists than you even will need to compete with (let's be honest, there are those on a different level). Anyways, this is just coming from someone who has tried many different forms of animation and gained a lot of experience (though I really don't have any "full" animations out yet).
Pay more attention to detail (especially the lines you put on your sticks, you may want to go to the line tool for a while)
5/10 for now,
I hope to see more.