truth
First off, just because you don't create flash movies, doesn't mean that you can't tell when something isn't very good.
I have seen alot of movies on newgrounds, I haven't made any of my own. But I can honestly say, that you need to work on this.
They fps rate was way too low. Made the movie look choppy. Mario's voice was terribly distorted and was way beyond the proper sound levels. Whoever recorded it was in the red the whole time.
It was short, and very little happened. The vote 5 piece at the end, is something that you should never put in a flash. It is very rare that any flash gets a solid 5 or even a 4 for that matter.
The file size was ridiculous for how short it was, and I attribute that to the music file at the end.
And to finish this up...... Just because you don't create, doesn't mean you can't tell what talent and "good art" is.