Reviews for Metal1 - Zhuriel VS cowdog2

[carnagereap]

Not bad.

But Zhuriel seemed like he didn't play in the right scale, just a couple of notes out of place. Cowdog2, I like yours a tab better, pretty much because you didn't rely on tricks (I.E. Tremolo bar, kill switch). Zhuriel, you need to work on your techniques a little more. The whammy bar is cool and all, but don't use it too much. Same for killswitch. Take a little bit of music theory. Look at some lessons online and learn scales. You seem like the kind of person who doesn't do that kind of stuff.

I give it to Cowdog2

thecoreman responds:

Thanks for voting man, your time will come soon :P Appreciated, and counted for the final vote.

[cowdog2]

MAAN

FINNAALLY we got a battle here AND I must say this is a pretty badass lil track. Zhuriel, badass job on your solo, Like the intro very much and you have a badass tone in your recording. Just wish the mixxing was a lil better, the solo was a bit too loud.

also thank you guys for the reviews, much appreciated. CAN't wait for round 2

thecoreman responds:

Great solo man! Congrats on the win!

[Ritari]

yessssssss

Yo cowdog I don't think I could have done a better job, and this is my track!

thecoreman responds:

YES.

[HighBallers]

hahaha.....goddamnit I fucked sucked but then. omg I'm cringing soo hard hahaha. This is my new account for Cowdog2.

[Pure-Metal-UTA]

Great work!

I listened to the backing track seperately and felt it wasn't my type of metal. But nonetheless good!
Regarding the mixing, Zhuriel's solo was too loud and cowdog's to just right. I couldn't hear the backing track over Zhuriel's shredding.
Now to review the solos:
Zhuriel
I personally felt that it needed more than picking a single note and changing it every little bit. That being said, it was still decent and went along with the song. The beginning part was excellent though, and the effects were good.
Cowdog2
I really like the melodicness of this one, although there were off notes and sometimes misplaced notes (if you know what i mean) You show excellent control of the fretboard, and i like that!
My vote goes to cowdog2

thecoreman responds:

Thanks for voting and supporting dude. Appreciated, and counted for the final vote.