this was awsome
thank you for making this song. it was as great as your other singles. i like how it reminds of the lord of the rings. it really does. im surprised how its this empowering. i figured it would be sad
Reviews for "-RG- In a Teardrop"
Raven-Guard responds:
Awesome, thanks man :).
Yeah, the name is pretty sad, but it has a catchy ring to it, don't you think? xD.
Thanks again for reviewing ^^.
--
Supersteph54
Great song.
Who cares if it sounds a bit like Requiem for a Dream? Hell, that song was great. But this takes it to a whole new dimension. I'm liking the epic feel with those crisp string and horn notes, and the drums fit in perfectly.
5/5, 10/10, fav'd.
Raven-Guard responds:
Thanks man. Yeah I really don't agree with Enteroar :(.
The brass in this song was supposed to give the dark feel, driven on by an epic feel from the strings, so I'm glad you like them :3.
Thanks again for the great and supportive review!
--
Supersteph54
This is fabulous!
I could listen to this song over and over for who knows how long, and never get bored of it! You guys really did a great job constructing this song!
Raven-Guard responds:
Thanks! We try to vary our songs as much as possible, so we're glad you don't find it boring.
Thanks again for the review :D.
--
Supersteph54
lol..
Sounds like you dled the midi for Req for a dream and editted the notes alitte -.-
Raven-Guard responds:
Yeah, because last time I checked, Requiem for a Dream had a xylophone, had the same drum style as this, had almost all the notes exactly the same, had a similar structure and was 3 minutes and 37 seconds long.
FAIL.
Darklight17 took care of the melodies. Maybe he was inspired by Requiem for a Dream, but if you take a listen at Requiem for a dream, sure it has similar foreground notes for around the first 5 notes of the melody, but it morphs completely from there. Is there anything wrong with being inspired by a song? Hell, I don't even know if he WAS inspired by it or the melody just came to him.
Also the chords in the background aren't at all like the chords of Requiem for a Dream.
By the way, we have never downloaded or touched the Requiem for a Dream MIDI file. If we did and we uploaded it, that would be against the rules, as is posting in your review that you think a submission is stolen:
"If you believe an entry is stolen, do not comment about it in your review. If you are wrong, you may convince other users that the entry is stolen and you may cause a legitimate entry to receive an unfairly low score, or have the whistle blown on it."
In case you can't be bothered to read it, basically that means that YOU'RE breaking the rules and we're not.
Seriously, you'd think that someone would use their common sense and not call something stolen because it uses a few notes from another song.
I think you're not taking into account all the work we put into this. If we just grabbed the MIDI and 'editted the notes alittle -.-' then we'd have it done in a few minutes. This took us weeks and weeks of hard work.
I may seem like I'm overreacting, but if you put yourself in our shoes and you'd get someone calling your weeks of hard work a rip off of another song, you sure won't feel that happy, will you?
I respect your opinion, maybe you think it sounds like Requiem for a Dream, but if so, then don't give us a 7/10 and a review which might encourage more people to do like you just because you think it sounds like Requiem for a Dream. If you don't like that fact, then just DON'T REVIEW IT.
Thanks for the review nevertheless, I suppose. At least you didn't be extra retarded and give us a 0 or something.
--
Supersteph54