Reviews for Guitar Vs. Piano [ver. XCEED] (Goukisan Remix)

[Litening42]

Pretty Awesome!

I was a huge fan of the original, and this is a pretty amazing piece too. The only problem I have with it is the piano. It is not as strong as it was in Goukisan's piece. The original idea was to express two amazing instruments, the guitar and the piano. The song is amazing but I don't believe you have accomplished what Goukisan was trying to do, the guitar is there, but the piano is very lacking. Either increase the volume of the piano and add more to the piano piece that is already there. Other than that, this piece is awesome!
5/5
9/10

rtnario responds:

Very true. Actually, last year when I initially asked Goukisan for permission to remix the song, my idea was to "level-up" both the guitar and the piano and turn it into something like "Metal Vs. Orchestra". In the end, I decided to stick with my better more polished style of remixing songs, which would be to have the guitars up front and the piano, strings and synths in general at the back. I get the best results when I stick to my gut, and it didn't turn out bad.

Thanks for the detailed and constructive review!

[MasterMechaSonic]

Daaaaaaamn.

Hellofalot better than the original, I'll give it that. It got me hooked within the first 3 seconds. I'mma use this is a movie.

rtnario responds:

I did my best! And whoa, hold on, don't forget proper credit if you will. The official artist is "LEAF XCEED Music Division" (not rtnario) and the title is "Guitar Vs. Piano [ver. XCEED]". Thanks for the review, and hope you use this well if you decide to!

[phantomapache]

WOW NICE JOB!!!!!!!!!

This is my favorite song on all of new grounds keep up the good work.

rtnario responds:

Really? There are plenty that could top this, but I'm glad you think so anyways! Thanks.

[STARBUCKK]

Guitar Rock!

Rock On With Guitar!! Piano Is Good Too Respect =)

rtnario responds:

Piano is good...outnumbered, but good XD Thanks!

[ErikMcClure]

Louder Piano

Other then that, this is a dream come true. Expressive drums, chords, dynamic instruments, everything this song should be. You are amazing and probably the only artist on this planet capable of consistently coming out with metal songs that I actually like.

9/10
5/5

rtnario responds:

Wow, really? A review coming from someone like you, an already established artist means a lot to me. Thanks so much for the detailed review, and I hope that my future works reach expectation! =)