Reviews for Robotech Sentinels Part 1

[Walks-in-shadows]

Loved it

I mean I love robotech with all my heart. Its scary how much I love it in fact lol. Thats beside the point though, you really should make more of the series I mean I own the box set of the macross saga. It is a brillent series and when I want to remeber the good old days of waking up really early on a saturday mourning with a bowel of ceral watching robotech I can. You really should make more of it. I wished they would have continued making the sentinels series :( it would have been great to see Rick and lisa finally get married. Though in the box set they do show the wedding ,though not what comes after it. Anyways even if a few people see it, you have loyal fans waiting for your next one man. :) I know I will want to see more of it.

MedMapGuy responds:

Yes... I am beginning to see your point. Ya see... I'm a big fan of Robotech. Okay, BIIIIG fan. (The only problem why I'm not a BIIIIIIIG fan is because I don't own any of those Macross Valkyrie toy kits, or another other merchandise aside from the Wildstorm comics, four novels by Jack McKinney, and finally Robotech Art: 2. (Amazingly, the last two items were bought just this year in a local convention! I don't live in the States though)

Well anyway, I'm glad to hear from good folks such as yourselves - gives me that confidence to do another one! In fact, I'm already sketching various outfits for the Robotech Expeditionary Force - no more Southern Cross Spandex ala original Sentinels! (Sheeesh). I think I'll do a few more and HOPEFULLY I'll reach Lisa and Rick's wedding! Here's hoping! Then maybe I'll finally get to do an animated scene of the SDF3 folding to the Robotech Masters homeworld!!

[TotalFUException]

Very Nice.

I like how, unlike most other robotech submissions, this one sticks to the source material. Also a mice move to keep the text instead of adding voice actors.

MedMapGuy responds:

I saw a lack of Robotech stuff in this site and decided to do something about it. In the end, the results are good, but the number of people who watched it was a little too few to warrant a sequel... Maybe in the future? Who knows?

[Dusty-Gorilla]

Great!

You got a good thing going here. Lemme guess, drawn on paper, colored in photoshop, brought into Flash?

MedMapGuy responds:

Correct.

[Shulak]

Great, but...

That was great! Graphics are just excellent and I realy like it overall.

But, with no voice acting and the text passing to fast and the text was not always easy to read... that I didn't like. It was hard to follow the action. That's why I gave you 5 for the sound.

So if you can get 1 or 2 friends to help with the voice acting, I will give your entry an Overall of 8 or 9.

Keep up the good work.

MedMapGuy responds:

I understand these concerns, but unfortunately I don't feel that my voice or any of my peers would do justice to the film... Voice acting would make the whole thing feel rather silly to the overall experience.

Sorry about the text, I didn't realize it was so hard to read! I'll update ASAP to black font in most of the areas.

[SiaGrath]

Here's what I think

Hey dude that's was AWESOME!!!
You deserve an award or something
keep up the good work :D