WOW, nicely done
That is as good as i've seen here.
That was in my opinion great.
Not only was there a plot, but the detail of your characters, and care in lighting ,smooth movement was all good.
Thanx for the great submission.
Reviews for "Winter Attack (part 2)"
((( AS ALWAYS THE BEST )))
~~REVIEW~~
As always you make it look so easy great clay characters some of the best i seen around here in a very long time, the animation is intense and the story is awsome, make more soon...
~~THINGS TO IMPROVE ON~~
Basicly nothing since this is the best of the best, onlythin i would say would be to make more...
~~OVERALL~~
Awsome clay ever on this site, now make more please
~X~
That was very good
But i have a question: the snow on the ground, was that all white clay? If so, you must have got REALLY much clay.
Damn...nice...
Nice work. Your best yet if you ask me, which you didn't.
Wow, impressive and amusing!
When a full movie is split into two parts like this, i usually vote on both the same way but i only review the second part. Anyways both individual parts and the movie as a whole were just fantastic. I thought i recognized the smooth claymation right away. After seeing this along with Motion and Become i am really impressed with your abilities, and i think i can safely say that you are the most skilled claymator on this site. I was totally amazed by everything in this movie, not just the graphics, which is why i chose to review it. Here it is.
The graphics were as i already stated amazing, just like your other claymations. From what i know your method for creating cool looking characters is different from the other claymators on this site. I noticed you used a wire frame to make them look so lifelook, but i dont knoe if many people use these. Anyways what ever you do really works so dont change anything here. The characters are well designed, and not only in how they look. The environments and backgrounds in this case were probably a little better than in your other movies that i have seen, simply because they are artificial and not just a TV or a bookshelf or something. The environments were really well used by the characters as well. The main thing for the visuals, however, is the actual animation. It was almost mind blowing how smooth and percise all the movements were. The style was awesome too, the style of claymation is a little different than most, but nothing is too drastic. I rather enjoyed the idea of the movie, and of course how well it turned out. The idea was pretty simple, it doesnt take a lot of deep thought to understand it or anything but the way it was told was charming. It was told kind of like a fairly tale or a children's book, i definitely liked it. Then the story got a little more violent when the fight started and the bazooka was taken out, overall it was a good mix. But sadly in the second part of the movie some of that charming feel that the first part had was lost. It actually may have been for the best. And as for the ending of the first part you could not have chosen a better spot. It was the perfect cliffhanger, and im sure many more people watched the second part to see how it would end. The sound was awesome too, everything to do with it was excellent. The voice acting was great, from the expressions to the "narrator-like" script. The sound effects were good, but not much better because there werent too many of them. I know its very difficult to do many sounds in a claymation movie, but you still did good in making the sound seem complete. And the music was great too, from the cheerful music at the begining to the more intense piece in the second part, both suit the movie nicely.
Overall this was an amazing claymation movie. I still say you are the best claymator on the entire site, no one as been able to prove me wrong yet. And after seeing this i think i just have to put you into my favourite authors list. I definitely do not want to miss any of your future movies! So congrats on that and on a successful movie!
-Standing Ovation! 5/5
MackProductions responds:
I was hoping you'd review this.
Once again, you gave a brilliant review, thank you very much for these kind words. I really appreciate it, and am happy you enjoyed Winter Attack