Reviews for Rondoesque

[Step]

Yuck, MIDI... :P

Apart from the fact that the qualtiy is MIDI, this is out of this world! A very complicated piece, well varied, and it looks like you put heaps of work into it.

That piano is extraordinary. Harmonized perfectly with the saxophone, and really varied but still not feeling random. I liked the part at around 1:02 and at 1:37.

The saxophone's notes were very well done too. Good job with the crescendos, and the fast notes when it was getting to the end were fantastic.

The beginning and ending were both really good. It's just the ending that felt a little off, since the last note wasn't held long enough, and it ended slightly suddenly.

Very good piece, I enjoyed it quite a lot, especially the piano. Keep up the great work!
10/10
5/5
Sorry, no download. Classical isn't really my style... :\.

-Review Request Club-

sarias responds:

ok i know i said the last one was my best review ever but this is prolly better im kinda reviewing your review but your really good at it :) the ending is just this recording (theres actually a fermata at the end) i actually have a sax player lined up (i could do it but hes better then me :)) but i still need to find a piano player but it is soon to come thanks again for the review and its ok if classical aint your style :) I hate classical and baroque but its what you need to do to get into music school lol im more of a romantic on kinda guy on which i dont consider classical (compair clair de lune to mozart piano sonata compleatly different) lol im also a film music kind of guy but you gotta listen to all music to do that i mean john williams is basically a Stravinsky impersonator anyways thanks again for the review

[Calamaistr]

Excellent!

I hardly ever give 10's but this track does deserve one, its a beautiful harmony between two instruments my friend. I loved every part of it so ill add this one to my favorites.

i would like to hear more like this from you :)

sarias responds:

why thank you lol I spent a lot of time on this one, and my university (ASU) didn't like it very much because its too conservative, but if it would have been written 150 years ago it would be fine lol gotta hate modern music thanks for the review

[Haggard]

Good

Midi sounds awful, but I guess you know that already. I would really like to hear this with a real saxophone. The melody is nice and pretty catchy. This all is backed up with a nice piano in the background.

Good work on composing, now you just need to find a way to record a real sax. ;)

{ Review Request Club }

sarias responds:

oh it will happen when i have the tools to do so I have a sax player (i could do it but I was 3rd chair in regionals and he was 1st and 2nd in all state i didn't make it lol) to play it for me now i just need to find a piano player because to be honest im an ok pianist but this is a little beyond me

thanks again for the review

[Coop]

Well worked

It's a piece that reminds me of theme music for some sort of 1980s Agatha Christie crime drama production. I really like it, as it has that tone of suspense from the piano, led along nicely by the commanding tones of the saxophone. Perhaps it could have used a lower solo, just to re-assert itself, away from the piano, as that can tend to become more dominant after a while - it's the nature of the instrument.

It loops really well, so I can certainly see this getting quite a versatile market that it can be used for. Another great piece from you and I'll look forward to hearing more.

[Review Request Club]

sarias responds:

the volume of it is completely wrong when i get my sax player to play it it should be better never though agatha christie but cool :) thanks for the review and im looking forward to giving you more to listen to

[Soapbubble]

Composition? Perfect

===============
Score: 9 / 10
Summary: Composition? Perfect
Review: Tell you what. When you record this with a saxophone and get rid of that hideous MIDI, I'll 10/10 it, 5/5 it and add it to favorites.

No, I don't really like classical music, but this is great music. The "saxophone" go great with the piano. Harmonize perfectly together. The composition is well structured, and it's a soothing piece, something my dad can agree with. He was standing behind me when I listened to it.

I read Coop83's review, and I agree, this would slide easily into an 80s crime series.

The volume of the sax and piano doesn't go very well, though. Sax is a prominent instrument, so make sure it doesn't kill out the other instruments, if you want them all in.

A great piece. Looking forward to more from ya!

-=Review Request Club=-
===============

sarias responds:

ok i will let you know when all that is done thank you so much for the review :)